Showing posts with label Parenting Book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Parenting Book. Show all posts

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Naomi Aldort's Parenting Philosophy: Excellent, But NOT for Everyone

Along with the controversy surrounding Naomi's bogus PhD, there have been numerous book reviews and comments on Amazon.com and other forums regarding the advice that Naomi gives to parents about raising their children.

In case you are not familiar with her book, Raising Our Children, Raising Ourselves, I will try to give you a brief synopsis.  The sub-title explains that her ideas, when put into practice, will transform the parent-child relationship from reaction and struggle to freedom, power and joy.  The basic principal of Naomi's teachings is that children deserve to be treated with the same respect and trust as is befitting any adult.  Her book asserts that lack of age or life experience does not make someone less worthy of freedom, autonomy and self-regulation.  She suggests that parents need only provide compassion, patience, emotional security and unconditional love in order to raise joyful, powerful children.  (If you fully understand her book, you will know that the word power is easily replaced with autonomy.) 

It sounds simple, right?  Wouldn't every parent gladly give up conflicts with their children in favour of living in freedom and peace?  Of course! But not all parents are equally capable of achieving this amazing equilibrium in their homes.  Here are some reasons why.

1.  Some parents confuse Freedom with License.
Freedom is what happens when a group of people mutually agree to respect each other's needs as equal to their own.  Freedom is NOT license to do whatever you want. 

One area where Naomi's book is easily misunderstood is how she suggests that children should be allowed to determine their own bodily rhythms when it comes to food and sleep.  Some parents would think that she is suggesting that children should stay up late into the night as much as they want or that children can choose to eat nothing but ice cream.  No, that is not Naomi's strategy at all.

Consider the act of driving a car.  One must follow the rules of the road, purchase insurance and keep the car safely maintained.  Having the Freedom to hop in the car and drive wherever and whenever we please is not the same as having the License to break the speed limits, run stop signs and drive on the sidewalk.  By choosing to drive, we choose to respect our own need for safety and the safety of others.

The food and sleep issue for children is the same.  Few parents would find that the family functions well when one or more members choose to sleep in patterns that disrupt the rhythm of the rest of the family.  And few parents would be comfortable with their children never choosing to eat a fruit or vegetable.  However, if the parent creates an environment where any available choice for food or sleep will be acceptable to all members of the family, then there are no problems.

In my own family, all of the children lay down in bed at the same time in the evening, usually when the baby is ready for bed.  We talk about our day, tell what we are grateful for and sing songs.  If one or more of them are not tired then they get up to do a quiet activity when the others fall asleep.  Later, they go to bed on their own or whenever I decide to go to bed.  We also have an agreement that every Sunday everyone stays up and we do a family activity like watching a movie or having a campfire.  There is no fighting about 'bedtime' and everyone gets enough sleep.

Freedom to choose whatever food the child wants is similarly easy:  Simply don't bring food into your home that you don't want your children to eat.  Some days one of my daughters will consume nothing but toast and soy milk.  This is no problem for me because generally the next day her body will be craving some fiber and she'll eat lots of raw fruits and vegetables (which are always plentiful).  If my house has potato chips in it, it is no surprise to me that my children will not touch anything healthy because they can only think about the junk food.  If it's not available, they will eat whatever IS available.

Freedom to make one's own choices within the boundaries of what is good for everyone is just life.  Boundaries are not rules.

2.  Some parents don't know how to be the Leader in their homes.

Most of us are really good at being The Boss.  We grew up in a school environment where we were permitted limited autonomy and the adult was always in charge.  Many of us had home environments that were the same as school where our parents were authoritarian.  We bring this familiar paradigm to the parenting of our own children because it is comfortable and common.

Some of us are really bad at being The Boss.  We're the Pushovers.  We are so afraid of creating disappointment or sadness or frustration for our children that we give them whatever they want and offer them no boundaries, values or priorities of our own because we don't want to clash with them.  We seek their love and approval rather than unconditionally giving ours.

Neither of those scenarios are ones in which the parents have a clear sense of what is best for themselves OR their children.  A Leader creates authentic boundaries by living within clearly defined Values and Priorities.  You might consider establishing a Family Mission Statement as a way of clearly defining your own Values and Priorities. 

For example, if healthy eating and exercise is important to you, then you are a Leader by engaging in a healthy lifestyle and not creating a home full of junk foods where the most common activity is watching TV.  You aren't being a Leader if you make your kids eat veggies and rice while you eat fries and cheese dip.  That's obvious, right? 

Similarly, if a tidy home is important to you then you better keep it clean.  A BOSS creates rules about making everyone clean up.  A PUSHOVER complains about the mess but does nothing OR cleans up constantly as the Cinderella who is serving everyone else's needs.  A LEADER cleans up and shows everyone around her the benefits of order and cleanliness. 

Being the Leader is what prevents your home environment from becoming one of License rather than Freedom.  We are not to become the servant of our children, running ourselves ragged to meet their every demand.  A Leader models self-care and self-love.  A Leader states clearly her own needs and limitations and then acts in such a way as to meet her needs and surrender to her limitations.

For example, my two older children love to go to playgrounds, especially during the school year when there are few other children there.  I am totally committed to following their agendas and facilitating their play and learning, but I really dislike going to playgrounds because Julian is at an age (12 months) where the playground is very dangerous for him with his limited physical abilities and his enormous curiosity (and total lack of sense!)  It is exhausting for me to play with him at the playground and keep him safe while also assisting his sisters on the monkey bars and pushing them on swings and watching them do acrobatics on the climbers.  I have explained this to my daughters (ages 5 and 7) and I have asked them to go to playgrounds only when their dad is available to either go with them or stay home with Julian.  This is being the Leader.

3.  Some parents are not very good at self-analysis.
One of Naomi's most important suggestions is that parents STOP their reactions to their children from being expressed and just listen and observe them in our heads.  This pause gives us the time to consider how our reactions might hurt our relationships with our children.  Instead we should question our reactions and ask ourselves how we will connect with our child in that moment.

Some people are just not very good at this because they are convinced that the story playing in their own heads is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.  They are not good at examining their stories and finding out why it might be wrong. 

For example, one time I was at an indoor playground with my children and when we reached the 'agreed upon time' for leaving, my daughter Jasmine refused to put on her coat and boots.  I panicked and I told myself a story:  The baby needs to sleep and we have to get on the next bus or else wait for 30 minutes!  I picked up Jasmine, forced her into her boots and dragged her out the door.  It was terrible.  In that moment I was believing my story and I was being The Boss instead of The Leader. 

Some parents might say, "Well, she should have left when you told her it was time.  And besides, you had to take care of the baby so the older child can't always get what she wants."  It's easy to get sucked into believing that story.  But I know it to be false.  If I had played out that horrible, aggressive reaction in my head (rather than doing it for real) I would have experienced how terrible I was going to feel afterwards.  I would have seen her sad face and scared little eyes in my mind and I would have chosen a different course of action.  How do I know I did the wrong thing?  Because of the guilt I felt afterwards!  Guilt is always your heart's way of telling you that you made the wrong choice. 

Through my phone sessions with my life coach Tara Wagner (The Organic Sister) and through reading, watching and listening to The Work of Byron Katie, I have become much, much better at stopping my reactions and doing some self-analysis.  By keeping my connection with my children as my top priority, I have learned to control my sharp tongue, offer more validation and listen better to their needs. 

4.  Some parents are not confident doing things differently from their family and friends.
Do you know how many times in a week I hear the phrase "Wow.  You're brave."  It's always in regards to how I have 4 young children, or how we don't send our children to school, or how we practice selective vaccinations, or how we are six people living in a 2-bedroom bungalow, or how we swing amortage in Toronto on one income, or how....whatever.  And it never means that the speaker thinks I am a woman of courage.  It means that the speaker thinks I am a total oddball who is doing everything completely differently from the mainstream.

Well, good.  Because I AM doing everything differently from the mainstream.  And I am completely confident in my choices.  I know what I value.  I know my priorities.  I believe in my ability to learn and grow and change and create so that my family and I can live the life of Freedom and Joy that we all want and deserve.

But I totally understand that not every parent feels as confident as I do about making choices that are different from what everyone else does.  I have 2 friends who are really uncertain about sending their children to public school.  Neither of them want their children to be 'different' but neither of them is convinced that public school is the right place for their children.  One of the mothers, after a year of uncertainty, has decided to try part-time schooling.  The other mother has enrolled her child but is 'fighting' with the school principal about accommodating her daughter's needs.  BOTH mothers have made big, BIG choices to go against the mainstream in making decisions about their children.  Simply questioning the status quo is an ENORMOUS act of courage sometimes, and I have nothing but admiration for these two moms for having the confidence to act against the mainstream. 

5.  Some parents are looking for a technique to create a certain behaviour in their children.
Aaah, this is a biggee, my friends.  Most parents buy parenting books because they are looking for a set of strategies or techniques to 'fix' their child.  Naomi's book will not fix anything about your child because Naomi's philosophy is that there is nothing wrong with your child.  The only thing that Naomi's strategies will fix is the parents' reactions to their child.  Her ideas and techniques are all about trusting the child and deepening the parent-child relationship.

If you are looking for ways to make your child conform or comply (which most mainstream parents want more than anything) then this is absolutely the wrong book for you.  The strategies in this book will only work in so much as the parent is willing to change, adapt, reflect, question and lead.  There are no rules, no punishments, no incentives, no rewards and no techniques that will change your child into someone better.  There is only Trust, Freedom, Autonomy and Joy.  When parents are willing to open their hearts to living their own Trust, Freedom, Autonomy and Joy, they will simply open up every relationship to experience the same things.

I believe it is possible for everyone to choose a parenting trajectory that brings Freedom and Joy to their families.  Not everyone who reads Naomi's book is ready to begin that journey.

How about you?  Do you have any further questions about how I have used Naomi Aldort's parenting advice to find Freedom and Joy in my relationships with my children?  Did something in this post resonate with you?  Please leave a comment or consider sending me a private email.

Freedom and Joy to you and yours, my kind friends and followers.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Connection, Communication, Compassion

Welcome to the July Carnival of Natural Parenting: Parenting Philosophy

This post was written for inclusion in the monthly Carnival of Natural Parenting hosted by Code Name: Mama and Hobo Mama. This month our participants have shared their parenting practices and how they fit in with their parenting purpose. Please read to the end to find a list of links to the other carnival participants.
***



My parenting journey has already taken me on a route I could never have imagined before my children were born.  I was a career-driven woman, proud of my university degrees, moving up the ladder of success.  At 30, I was completing my Masters degree and I was just a couple of years away from becoming a vice-principal.  I owned a swanky downtown condominium.  I really thought I had things figured out.

Then I had a baby.  Then I had a few more.

I understood a little about Attachment Parenting in the early days of motherhood.  And when we decided not to send our kids to school I learned a lot more.

Along my journey I discovered Naomi Aldort and her book Raising Our Children, Raising Ourselves.  I discovered Nonviolent Communication.  I learned about living organically.  And most recently I discovered The Work of Byron Katie.

All of these ideas have helped to shape my parenting practices and I have synthesized them into 3 C's.

  • Connection  Whenever I am feeling conflicted or confused about sleep, food or freedom, I ask myself Are my actions going to sustain and deepen my connection with my child or drive a wedge between us?
  • Communication  When anger or frustration bubbles, I stop to choose words that are gentle.  I ask myself Will my child feel loved or separated by my words?
  • Compassion  When I am overwhelmed (or my child is), I remember that my child is still new to the experience of LIFE and that I am the adult with the power to help or hurt.

Along with these 3 C's I have also come to develop an understanding of the importance of  4 EXPERIENCES OF TRUST.
  • The mother must trust her instinct to do what is best for her children.
  • The mother must trust her children to signal their authentic needs.
  • The children must freely trust that the mother is acting in their best interests.  (This happens when a child's trust has not been violated.)
  • The mother must open her heart to accept the authentic trust of the children.
(Of course, the concept of the 4 TRUSTs applies equally to all parents, not just the mother.)

It's all about the relationship.  Because if the relationship isn't the priority, then what is?

Have you synthesized several parenting 'philosophies' into one that makes sense for you?


***

Carnival of Natural Parenting -- Hobo Mama and Code Name: MamaVisit Code Name: Mama and Hobo Mama to find out how you can participate in the next Carnival of Natural Parenting!

Please take time to read the submissions by the other carnival participants:

(This list will be live and updated by afternoon July 12 with all the carnival links.)

  • Between Love and Fear: On Raising our Children Sensibly — Mamma Earthly at Give an Earthly discusses the fear factor in parenting and how she overcame it, despite societal pressures.
  • really, when do i get my cape? — Sarah at small bird on fire is a working city mama trying to learn how to set aside her expectations of perfection and embrace the reality of modern parenting.
  • Baby, Infant, and Toddler Wearing — Child wearing is part of Sarah at Nourished and Nurtured's parenting philosophy. In this post, Sarah describes benefits of child-wearing and gives tips for wearing babies, infants, and toddlers (even while pregnant).
  • First Year Reflections — As her daughter's first birthday approaches, Holly at First Year Reflections reflects on how she and her husband settled into attachment parenting after initially doing what they thought everyone else did.
  • Making an allowance — Lauren at Hobo Mama welcomes a guest post from Sam about the unexpected lessons giving a four-year-old an allowance teaches the child — and the parent.
  • How to be a Lazy Parent and Still Raise Great Kids — Lisa at Granola Catholic talks about how being a Lazy Parent has helped her to raise Great Kids.
  • Philosophy in Practice — Laura at A Pug in the Kitchen shares how her heart shaped the parenting philosophy in her home.
  • What is Attachment Parenting Anyway? — Gaby at Tmuffin describes the challenges of putting a label on her parenting philosophy.
  • Of Parenting Styles — Jenny at Chronicles of a Nursing Mom talks about how she and her husband tailored various parenting styles to fit their own preferred parenting philosophy.
  • Moment by Moment Parenting — Amy at Peace 4 Parents encourages those who care for children (including herself) to explore and appreciate parenting moment-by-moment with clarity, intention, trust, and action.
  • Maintaining Spirituality in the Midst of Everyday Parenting, Marriage, and Life — Sarah at Nourished and Nurtured shares her perspective on finding opportunities for spiritual growth in every day life.
  • Parenting Philosophy — Lily, aka Witch Mom's parenting philosophy is to raise child(ren) to be compassionate, loving, inquisitive, and questioning adults who can be trusted to make decisions for themselves in a way that avoids harming others.
  • Long Term — Rosemary at Rosmarinus Officinalis thinks about who she would like to see her daughter become — and what she can do now to lay a strong foundation for those hopes.
  • Connection, Communication, Compassion — She's come a long way, baby! After dropping her career in favour of motherhood, Patti at Jazzy Mama discovered that building solid relationships was going to be her only parenting priority.
  • My Parenting Inspirations - Part 4 — Jennifer at Hybrid Rasta Mama looks at her biggest parenting inspiration and how that translates into her long-term parenting philosophy.
  • A Parenting Philosophy in One Word: Respect — Jenn at Monkey Butt Junction summarizes her parenting and relationship philosophy in one word: respect.
  • Knowledge and Instinct — Kat at Loving {Almost} Every Moment believes that knowledge and instinct are super important … as are love, encouragement and respect. It's the ideal combo needed to raise happy and healthy children and in turn create meaningful relationships with them.
  • THRIVE! — The Sparkle Mama wants to set a tone of confidence, abundance, and happiness in her home that will be the foundation for the rest of her daughter's life.
  • On Children — "Your children are not your children," say Kahlil Gibran and Hannah at Wild Parenting.
  • This One Life Together — Ariadne aka Mudpiemama shares her philosophy of parenting: living fully in the here and now and building the foundation for a happy and healthy life.
  • Enjoying life and planning for a bright future — Olivia at Write About Birth shares her most important parenting dilemmas and pours out her heart about past trauma and how healing made her a better parent.
  • My Parenting Philosophy: Unconditional and Natural Love — Charise at I Thought I Knew Mama shares what she has learned about her parenting philosophy from a year of following her instincts as a mama.
  • An open letter to my children — Isil at Smiling Like Sunshine writes an open letter to her children.
  • My Starter Kit for Unconditional Parenting — Sylvia at MaMammalia discusses her wish to raise a good person and summarizes some of the nontraditional practices she's using with her toddler son in order to fulfill that wish.
  • Responsiveness — Sheila at A Gift Universe has many philosophies and goals, but what it all boils down to is responsiveness: listening to what her son wants and providing what he needs.
  • Tools for Creating Your Parenting Philosophy — Have you ever really thought about your parenting purpose? Knowing your long-term goals can help you parent with more intent in your daily interactions. Dionna at Code Name: Mama offers exercises and ideas to help you create your own parenting philosophy.
  • Be a Daisy — Becky at Old New Legacy philosophizes about individuality and how she thinks it's important for her daughter's growth.
  • What's a Mama to Do? — Amyables at Toddler in Tow hopes that her dedication to compassionate parenting will keep her children from becoming too self-critical as adults.
  • grown-up anxieties. — Laura at Our Messy Messy Life explains her lone worry concerning her babies growing up.
  • Why I Used Montessori Principles in My Parenting Philosophy — Deb Chitwood at Living Montessori Now tells why she chose Montessori principles to help her now-adult children develop qualities she wanted to see in them as children and adults.
  • Parenting Philosophies & Planning for the Future — Momma Jorje considers that the future is maybe just a fringe benefit of doing what feels right now.
  • Not Just Getting Through — Rachael at The Variegated Life asks what truths she hopes to express even in the most commonplace interactions with her son.
  • Parenting Philosophy? Eh... — Ana at Pandamoly shares the philosophy (or lack thereof) being employed to (hopefully) raise a respectful, loving, and responsible child.
  • Parenting Philosophy: Being Present — Shannon at The Artful Mama discusses the changes her family has made to accommodate their parenting philosophy and to reflect their ideals as working parents.
  • Who They Will Be — Amanda at Let's Take the Metro shares a short list of some qualities she hopes she is instilling in her children at this very moment.
  • Short Term vs. Long Term — Sheryl at Little Snowflakes recounts how long term parenting goals often get lost in the details of everyday life with two kids.
  • Parenting Philosophy: Practicing and Nurturing Peace — Terri at Child of the Nature Isle sets personal goals for developing greater peace.
  • Yama Niyama & the Red Pajama Mama — Part 1: The Yamas — In part 1 of a set of posts by Zoie at TouchstoneZ, Zoie guest posts at Natural Parents Network about how the Yoga Sutras provide a framework for her parenting philosophy.
  • Yama Niyama & the Red Pajama Mama — Part 2: The Niyamas — In part 2 of a set of posts by Zoie at TouchstoneZ, Zoie explores how the Niyamas (one of the eight limbs in traditional Yoga) help her maintain her parenting and life focus.
  • Our Sample Parenting Plan — Chante at My Natural Motherhood Journey shares hopes of who her children will become and parenting strategies she employs to get them there.
  • Philosophical Parenting: Letting Go — Jona at Life, Intertwined ponders the notion that there's no right answer when it comes to parenting.
  • Unphilosophizing? — jessica at instead of institutions wonders about the usefulness of navel gazing.
  • Parenting Sensitively — Amy at Anktangle uses her sensitivity to mother her child in ways that both nurture and affirm.
  • how to nurture your relationships — Mrs Green at Little Green Blog believes that sometimes all kids need is a jolly good listening to …
  • Philosophy Of An Unnatural Parent — Dr. Sarah at Good Enough Mum sees parenting as a process of guiding her children to develop the skills they'll need.
  • Life with a Challenging Kid: Hidden Blessings — Wendy at High Needs Attachment shares the challenges and joys of raising a high needs child.
  • Flying by the Seat of My Pants — Heather at Very Nearly Hippy has realized that she has no idea what she's doing.

Sunday, May 29, 2011

Homeschooling as the Next Step on the Continuum of Attachment Parenting

This post was written for inclusion in the Carnival of Homeschooling.  Please check out the other participants.

Recently someone was sharing with me how natural and 'easy' attachment parenting has been for her as she mothers her 4-month-old baby.  I smiled and agreed that Yes, it does make the parent's life so much easier to flow with the baby's needs.  But inside I was thinking And until what age do you intend to continue to attachment parent your child?

A bit obnoxious on my part?  Maybe.

But experience has shown me that even the most well-intentioned parents have a hard time committing to real attachment parenting after the baby-stage is over. My own experiences from 7+ years of being a mother (and I am by NO MEANS an expert) and my observations of mothers at La Leche League have taught me that the theories and practices that comprise the standard definition of 'attachment parenting' are much harder to keep in place as the baby becomes a toddler and a pre-schooler. In fact, one of the reasons why I resigned as a La Leche League leader was because I observed that many of the leaders (whose children were young like mine) were becoming more and more mainstream in their parenting practices as their children grew out of baby-hood.

When I was a new mother I thought I had a handle on the definition of attachment parenting. I had read the book by US paediatrician William Sears in which he set out a list of guidelines to describe attachment parenting. Generally speaking, his guidelines include:

Gentle birth
Breastfeeding on demand and child-led weaning
Babywearing
Bed-sharing
Immediate response to crying
Minimal separation of mother and baby
I followed these guidelines to a 'T' with Anna. In fact, there was no other way to care for Anna, as she cried whenever I put her down, she slept for no more than 45 minutes in the day before waking to nurse, and she would not stay with her dad for more than a few seconds if I left the room. I came to believe that attachment parenting meant having the child physically ON the mother, since even at 2 years old, Anna refused to be away from me for even a few minutes.

My understanding of attachment parenting began to change bit by bit when I started to ponder and research homeschooling. It was around Anna's 2nd birthday that I first began to think about homeschooling after a friend I had met at La Leche League told me that her husband was opposed to sending their daughter to school. I contacted the only person I knew at that time who was homeschooling, and she sent me the links to a variety of websites that she had found useful when she began homeschooling. I read through them, but nothing seemed to 'click' with me. Eventually, I ran across the term 'unschooling' and that eventually led me to the term 'authentic parenting'.

What I learned was that although I was following all the 'attachment parenting guidelines', I was doing it only for superficial reasons: I believed that by doing the things that Dr. Sears recommended (and La Leche League, also) I was a better mother than the cry-it-out, pro-daycare, pro-timeout crowd. Really, I had completely missed the point. I had been using a strategy but I had not fully committed to the essence of attachment which is the relationship.

I discovered unschooling through the website of Jan Hunt. It contains a wealth of articles by Hunt and others on parenting, health, learning and relationships. Jan Hunt's book is called The Natural Child: Parenting from the Heart. She renames attachment parenting 'empathic parenting' and she describes it thus:
We understand that all children are doing the very best they can at every given moment.

We trust that though children may be small in size, they deserve to have their needs taken seriously.

We know that it is unrealistic to expect a child to behave perfectly at all times.

We recognize that "bad behaviour" is the child's attempt to communicate an important need in the best way she can.

We learn to look beneath a child's outward behaviour to understand what he is thinking and feeling.

We see that in a very beautiful way, our child teaches us what love is.
When reading through this list of 'guidelines' it is easy to see how they apply to children of any age. Unlike the list of guidelines from Dr. Sears, these principles focus on a way of being in a relationship with a child. Jan Hunt says in her book that people either 'get it' about children, or they don't. It is only recently that I have begun to 'get it'. Trusting and respecting the emotions and actions of children all the time is a completely new way of thinking for me. It involves letting go of my pre-conceived ideas and making myself vulnerable to the needs of my children. Hunt offers me a challenge as opposed to the Dr. Sears list which offered only a strategy.

Authentic Parenting is described and taught by Naomi Aldort in her book Raising Our Children, Raising Ourselves. In the introduction she says

You will learn to nurture [your child] without shaping, like a gardener who waters flowers, but doesn't help them open nor choose their shapes or colors....

In this book you will learn to let go of your armour and let love flow through you with no strings attached.

If we want our future as humanity to look different than how it looks now, we need to allow our children to create it out of who they are and not out of who we want them to be.

Parenting is a path of maturation and growth if we dare to learn more and teach less. When you have the courage to stop defending the way you are, or the way your parents raised you, you can open up to the possibility that you are much greater and more magnificent and capable than you thought you were. (excepts from pages xv, xvi and xvii)


Reading these words was a lightbulb-moment for me. It made sense. It explained what was missing from my strategy for attachment parenting. It opened my mind and my heart to what was wrong with me instead of focusing on what I perceived to be wrong with my child. It gave me the courage to change.

Once I began to focus more on my relationship with my children, and less on trying to achieve a particular result with them, I was finally able to take a deep breathe and relax into my mothering role. It was no longer a persona and I began to experience more joy and freedom. By the time Jasmine joined our family I had fully made the switch in my mind from attachment parenting as a strategy to attachment parenting as a relationship. In fact, I felt that Jasmine's birth was like a renewal for my relationships with Anna and Holly. I felt like I was getting a fresh start, and as I looked for and met Jasmine's needs I learned to look for and meet Anna and Holly's needs in the same authentic way.

And this is why I am skeptical about people who embrace the principals of attachment parenting with their infants but who have a vision of the future with their children that includes pre-school or daycare or sleep-training or punishments or rewards or public school or schedules or any activities that require an otherwise dependent child to become prematurely independent.

Quite frankly, it's not easy to offer trust and respect to children all day, everyday, especially when they are no longer tiny and helpless. A daughter who refuses to help clean up her dolls or another daughter who screams at her father for serving her food with the wrong sauce do not necessarily inspire consistent kindness and patience, trust and respect. It's hard.

But it's worth it.

Focusing on the relationship instead of the behaviour removes the aspect of blame and maintains the equilibrium within the family. Attachment parenting is not a set of strategies. It is a way of life. It is a way of living with children. It is a way of loving that maximizes joy and freedom.

I'm learning. And I'm trying to share my experiences with anyone who wants to learn too.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

How I Learned to Define ' Attachment Parenting'

A few months ago when my mother returned from visiting my brother after the birth of his greatly-desired and long-anticipated first child, she commented to me "They sure are into the attachment parenting." And with my many years of experience as a mother, I couldn't help but think sarcastically, "Yeah. Let's see what they're doing in 5 years."

It's not that I don't think my brother and his partner will be good parents. They are older than me, they are completely devoted to their roles as parents, they treasure their son and went through a lot to have him in their lives. They are well-read, well-adjusted and well-schooled. They have a wealth of life experiences that I can never hope to achieve. Their relationship with each other is already long and solid.

It's just that experience has shown me that even the most well-intentioned parents have a hard time committing to real attachment parenting after the baby-stage is over. My own experiences from 6 years of being a mother and my observations of mothers at La Leche League have taught me that the theories and practices that comprise the standard definition of 'attachment parenting' are much harder to keep in place as the baby becomes a toddler and a pre-schooler. In fact, one of the reasons why I resigned as a La Leche League leader last year was because I observed that many of the leaders (whose children were young like mine) were becoming more and more mainstream in their parenting practices as their children grew out of baby-hood.

When I was a new mother I thought I had a handle on the definition of attachment parenting. I had read the book by US paediatrician William Sears in which he set out a list of guidelines to describe attachment parenting. Generally speaking, his guidelines include:

  • Gentle birth

  • Breastfeeding on demand and child-led weaning

  • Babywearing

  • Bed-sharing

  • Immediate response to crying

  • Minimal separation of mother and baby

I followed these guidelines to a 'T' with Anna. In fact, there was no other way to care for Anna, as she cried whenever I put her down, she slept for no more than 45 minutes in the day before waking to nurse, and she would not stay with her dad for more than a few seconds if I left the room. I came to believe that attachment parenting meant having the child physically ON the mother, since even at 2 years old, Anna refused to be away from me for even a few minutes.

My understanding of attachment parenting began to change bit by bit when I started to ponder and research homeschooling. It was around Anna's 2nd birthday that I first began to think about homeschooling after a friend I had met at La Leche League told me that her husband was opposed to sending their daughter to school. I contacted the only person I knew at that time who was homeschooling, and she sent me the links to a variety of websites that she had found useful when she began homeschooling. I read through them, but nothing seemed to 'click' with me. Eventually, I ran across the term 'unschooling' and that eventually led me to the term 'authentic parenting'.

What I learned was that although I was following all the 'attachment parenting guidelines', I was doing it only for superficial reasons: I believed that by doing the things that Dr. Sears recommended (and La Leche League, also) I was a better mother than the cry-it-out, pro-daycare, pro-timeout crowd. Really, I had completely missed the point. I had been using a strategy but I had not fully committed to the essence of attachment which is the relationship.

I discovered unschooling through the website of Jan Hunt. It contains a wealth of articles by Hunt and others on parenting, health, learning and relationships. Jan Hunt's book is called The Natural Child: Parenting from the Heart. She renames attachment parenting 'empathic parenting' and she describes it thus:



  • We understand that all children are doing the very best they can at every given moment.

  • We trust that though children may be small in size, they deserve to have their needs taken seriously.

  • We know that it is unrealistic to expect a child to behave perfectly at all times.

  • We recognize that "bad behaviour" is the child's attempt to communicate an important need in the best way she can.

  • We learn to look beneath a child's outward behaviour to understand what he is thinking and feeling.

  • We see that in a very beautiful way, our child teaches us what love is.

When reading through this list of 'guidelines' it is easy to see how they apply to children of any age. Unlike the list of guidelines from Dr. Sears, these principles focus on a way of being in a relationship with a child. Jan Hunt says in her book that people either 'get it' about children, or they don't. It is only recently that I have begun to 'get it'. Trusting and respecting the emotions and actions of children all the time is a completely new way of thinking for me. It involves letting go of my pre-conceived ideas and making myself vulnerable to the needs of my children. Hunt offers me a challenge as opposed to the Dr. Sears list which offered only a strategy.

Authentic Parenting is described and taught by Naomi Aldort in her book Raising Our Children, Raising Ourselves. In the introduction she says


You will learn to nurture [your child] without shaping, like a gardener who
waters flowers, but doesn't help them open nor choose their shapes or
colors....


In this book you will learn to let go of your armour and let love flow
through you with no strings attached.


If we want our future as humanity to look different than how it looks now, we need to allow our children to create it out of who they are and not out of who we want them to be.


Parenting is a path of maturation and growth if we dare to learn more and teach less. When you have the courage to stop defending the way you are, or the way your parents raised you, you can open up to the possibility that you are much greater and more magnificent and capable than you thought you were. (excepts from pages xv, xvi and xvii)


Reading these words was a lightbulb-moment for me. It made sense. It explained what was missing from my strategy for attachment parenting. It opened my mind and my heart to what was wrong with me instead of focusing on what I perceived to be wrong with my child. It gave me the courage to change.

Once I began to focus more on my relationship with my children, and less on trying to achieve a particular result with them, I was finally able to take a deep breathe and relax into my mothering role. It was no longer a persona and I began to experience more joy and freedom. By the time Jasmine joined our family I had fully made the switch in my mind from attachment parenting as a strategy to attachment parenting as a relationship. In fact, I felt that Jasmine's birth was like a renewal for my relationships with Anna and Holly. I felt like I was getting a fresh start, and as I looked for and met Jasmine's needs I learned to look for and meet Anna and Holly's needs in the same authentic way.

And this is why I am skeptical about people who embrace the principals of attachment parenting with their infants but who have a vision of the future with their children that includes pre-school or daycare or sleep-training or punishments and rewards or public school or schedules or any other activities that require an otherwise dependent child to become prematurely independent. Quite frankly, it's not easy to offer trust and respect to children all day, everyday, especially when they are no longer tiny and helpless. A daughter who refuses to help clean up her dolls or another daughter who screams at her father for serving her food with the wrong sauce do not necessarily inspire consistent kindness and patience, trust and respect. It's hard.

But it's worth it. Focusing on the relationship instead of the behaviour removes the aspect of blame and maintains the equilibrium within the family. Attachment parenting is not a set of strategies. It is a way of life. It is a way of living with children. It is a way of loving that maximizes joy and freedom.

I'm learning. And I'm trying to share my experiences with anyone who wants to learn too.

Friday, August 7, 2009

More on 'For the Sake of Our Children' by Leandre Bergeron

...children integrate into adult life when they are given the opportunity. I believe this what they want to do naturally and what school works so hard at systematically preventing. School is so absurd! How did we ever manage to phase our own children out of our lives and daily activities? How did we ever decide to deliver our children to strangers with questionable skills during the best hours of the day? (p. 83)

So says Leandre Bergeron about the manner in which his daughters learned to cook, bake, garden, book keep, raise animals, run a small business, drive tractor, butcher, read, write, sew, play piano and paint.

Incredible.

Bergeron's words describe exactly what I would describe as my primary reasons for keeping my children out of school. School is absurd. And standardized curriculum followed by standardized testing is the ultimate absurdity. As if some lackey at the Ministry of Education should have a say in how and when my children learn about reproduction or how the European explorers and settlers trampled over North America or the mysteries of global warming. Yikes.

"..strangers with questionable skills..." Well that definitely describes Partner-Guy and I as elementary school teachers. And yet our culture perpetuates that it is perfectly normal to hand your children over to a stranger everyday. I can't do it. I won't.

But my brain and my heart do get a little concerned for my children when I compare Bergeron's experience with his daughters to the current lifestyle of our little family. Bergeron was a well-travelled, well-educated, well-off guy by the time he had his children. He owned a 60-acre farm. He renovated a farmhouse, baled hay, raised chickens, geese, sheep and cows (for eggs, meat and milk). He owned a natural food store and supplied it with organic, hand-made bread baked in a wood-burning stove. He grew a substantial garden.

By contrast, our lives here in Toronto are pretty dull and boring. Too much shade prevents me from growing a garden. Animals are out of the question. I don't run a business. In other words, what are my children really going to learn at home with me, especially if I fully embrace unschooling by not teaching them (academic) lessons? It's a conundrum, that's for sure.

Wendy Preisnitz editted Bergeron's book. She is also the editor of Natural Life Magazine and the owner of Life Media. Her daughters never attended school. They learned as unschoolers as their parents created a publishing company and a magazine. Like Bergeron, Wendy Preisnitz gave her children a pretty amazing childhood from which to learn and grow and flourish.

I believe in it, but I'm not convinced I am capable of giving my daughters as rich a life as the daughters of Bergeron and Preisnitz experienced.

So what do I have to do? Move to a farm? Start a home business? I have plans to do both, but is it enough? How hard do I want to work? How green do I want to live? What would my lifestyle look like if it were to become completely authentic? And what if it takes me 5 more years to figure it out? Or 10 more years? Anna is already 5 years old......

In some ways, simply sending my children to school and just going back to my job would be so much easier. It would require no thought. No explanations. It would be mainstream. It would be normal.

But it would not be authentic.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Excellent, Excellent Book

For the Sake of Our Children by Leandre Bergeron is by far the most compelling book I've read in my journey as a mother. It has inspired me to change my habits and thinking.

This is the description from the LifeMedia Website:

For the Sake of Our Children by Léandre Bergeron
translated by Pamela Levac
foreword by John Taylor Gatto

A powerful description of a life led respecting and trusting children, from the naturalness of home birth and breastfeeding on demand, through learning by living and working together on a small farm and in a natural food store. The author's passionate ruminations about his strongly-held philosophies of attachment parenting and self-directed education are woven throughout a series of journal entries describing the daily life of a family of three unschooled teens. The result is a wonderfully warm, sometimes funny, always wise potpourri of advice and inspiration about natural parenting and unschooling from a father who writes, "I believe I have broken free from my complicity with other adults. I have chosen to remove myself from this adult world to side with children." This book provides both rationale for and proof of the wisdom of choosing a path that is so little trod upon in our world, the path of freedom, of respect for our children, of trust in them and belief in their ability to regulate and educate themselves.

"You are about to encounter the amazing tale of Léandre Bergeron and his three born-at-home daughters as they educated themselves on the family farm. If you attend sharply while you read, you will discern under its quiet style a profoundly revolutionary narrative which, if imitated widely, would turn the North American education world (or any other) upside down, with incalculable effects...Bergeron’s commitment to full human rights for the young is so unstinting it challenges many child-rearing conventions that most of the rest of us take for granted. In that very surprising commitment resides much of this book’s power. It inspires reflection, causing the reader to ask as he or she might have done on their own account long ago: 'Why are we doing this?' 'What do we hope to gain?' Bergeron’s text compels such introspection." ~ John Taylor Gatto

About the Author: Léandre Bergeron is a well-known author and activist who was born in Manitoba. He studied in France and taught literature at Concordia University in Montreal before moving to the Quebec countryside with his lovely wife Francine to live a life of voluntary simplicity. His many works range from a guide to home birth to the well-known Dictionnaire de la langue québecoise and the best-seller, Petit Manuel d'histoire du Québec, which has recently been updated and re-released. He is a tireless champion for the underdog and has long advocated for educational, political and social reform. Parents from all over Quebec seek his advice about homeschooling their own children.


Here is a paragraph that has stuck with me like a knife in the heart:


Why is there often a break in the relationship with our children? At
birth, we gaze at her in awe and we are centered on our child. We find her
to be beautiful, amazing and everything else, but one day, sooner rather than
later, this initial wonder is extinguished. Our daily routine doesn't
encourage feelings of respect for our child but, instead, becomes the chore of
"raising" her....Our child is no longer the miracle she once was, but an
obligation... (pp. 35-36)

I think this has happened to me with my kids. It has definitely happened in my relationship with Anna, and somewhat less so with Holly and Jasmine. Now that I am fully aware that a shift in my attitude toward Anna has caused a break, an injury, in my relationship with her, my new obligation is to mend it.

I have known for a while that Anna gets far less attention from me than her sisters get. It is hard for me to balance the needs of three little people everyday without sometimes getting overwhelmed, and it is Anna who has suffered the most. I think I expect too much out of her. She is only 5 years old. I can't expect her to be more mature than she is able to be.

So here is my plan to re-engage with her and to mend the break in our relationship.

  1. Be physically engaged. When Anna talks I must make eye contact with her. I must take her hand before she reaches for mine. I must cuddle her and welcome her affection, even when I am busy with other things.
  2. Draw her to me. I must welcome her dependence. I must offer to do things for her and not act annoyed or overwhelmed when she asks me for something.
  3. Stop second-guessing her. I must look for and retrieve the trust that I had in her when she was an infant. As an infant, I trusted her to show me her needs and I would meet them unconditionally. I must return to this practice of trust, respect and confidence in her to know herself.
  4. Stop instructing. She doesn't need every little episode of life to become a big lesson that she must remember and learn from. I must let her observe and ask questions. She will learn better from her own experiences than from the sound of my voice droning in her ear.


I will give a full review of For the Sake of Our Children by Leandre Bergeron after I have read it a few more times. It is certainly worth savouring again and again.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Authentic Parenting

I have latched onto this title as an apt description of my style of parenting, or at least as a description of the style of parenting that I aspire to. I first saw it on the website of Naomi Aldort, whose book, Raising Our Children Raising Ourselves, is my handbook and reference for how to be the kind of parent that I want to be.

I will give a full review of Naomi's book another day, but I can summarize her basic theory thus: It is but the job of the parent to celebrate who the children already are and to provide opportunities for the children to fully explore and achieve their full potentials. The parent must be the leader and must trust that the children are always doing their best.

I am working hard to let of go the notion that I must control my children or that they must obey me. Tonight, for example, when Holly wanted to stay in the bath after the other two girls were already out, dried and ready for bed, I told her without drama that Jasmine was tired and needed to go to bed now and that I didn't want to wait any longer. I said nothing more and got busy cleaning up the bathroom, and in just a minute or two she happily got out of the tub. I didn't beg or bribe or demand that she get out, and I felt good about giving her the information and then letting her make her own decision. And when she got out I didn't give her any drama by praising her for getting out. I just smiled at her and carried on with the task of getting her ready for bed.

For me, it is those simple situations that I struggle with much more than the big situations like when Anna and Holly are fighting or when Jasmine refuses to wear a diaper. The situations that could easily lead to trying to control the children seem to be very obvious to me, and I am able to stop myself before I react with anger or dominance. But the little situations like tonight with Holly sometimes lead me to try to dominate and then I end up creating a struggle where I have to win and the child has to lose. It is my genuine goal to completely eliminate that type of parenting from our home completely.

One struggle I continue to have is that although it is easy for me to celebrate the authenticity of my children, it is hard for me to celebrate my own authenticity. For one thing, I'm not sure what aspects of myself are authentic, and what aspects are simply the result of following rules and listening to other people's opinions of me for the last 35 years. Most of my habits and personality that seem to be authentically me are traits that I don't like about myself and would like to hide. In fact, most of the time my negative self-talk tells me that I am not good enough to raise such wonderful daughters and that they will far eclipse me in their talents and successes and that they will grow up with nothing but disdain for me. Yup, it's hard to want to be authentic when almost everyone I've ever known has rejected me once they started to know what I was really all about.

Nonetheless, I believe in the style of parenting described by Naomi Aldort so much that I have decided to take a course from her, not just to help me be a better mommy, but also to further my goal of eventually being a parent educator. I plan to get started on her course in the fall (it is partly via teleconferencing and partly online) and I will likely need to work on it for up to a year. Since I will be returning to work (as a teacher) in January I may have a lot on my plate, but I intend to really pursue this new career and to quit my job permanently in March. We'll see!!

The cover of Naomi's book says "Transforming the Parent-Child Relationship from Reaction and Struggle to Freedom, Power and Joy."

Exactly.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Still Thinking This Out....

One of my few friends from the days when I wore big bangs, black eye liner and tapered jeans recently recommended a parenting book which she found really helpful. I am extremely resistant to parenting books, since they tend to have very mainstream content, but since I have a great deal of respect for this friend and fellow blogger (check her out here) I went to Indigo and picked up the book.



Hold Onto Your Kids by Dr. Gordon Neufeld



I haven't finished reading it yet, but so far it is an exact fit with my own parenting philosophies. This particular passage has stuck in my head.



It takes three ingredients to make parenting work: a dependent being in need of
being taken care of, an adult willing to assume rsponsibility, and a good
working attachment from the child to the adult. the most critical of thises is
also the one most commonly overlooked and neglected: the child's attachment to
the adult. Many parents and would-be parents stil labor under the misconception
that once can simply step into the role of parenting, .... We expect that the
child's need to be taken care of and our willingness to parent will suffice. We
are surprised and aoffended when children seem resistant to our parenting.




His words remeinded me of a passage I wrote last month.

I've been formulating a thesis on the idea that TRUST is the most important
element in the parent-child relationship. My idea revolves around the idea of a
tripartite trust: the parents must trust themselves (this is the basis of
following your instinct and thinking with your heart), the parents must trust
the child (this is the basis of not making the child do things he/she is not
ready for) and the parents must accept the trust of the child (this is the basis
by which the child's physical, emotional and social needs are met). I think that
many of the parents who I regard as attachment parents are practising these
three components of the tripartite trust, but there are many good parents who I
meet, who are missing one component or another. And I have met many parents who
instinctively practise the three trusts, but only until their child can talk, or
walk, or go to kindergarten, as though there is a cut-off point where you have
to do what the SuperNanny says, and start to make your child into something or
other. Anyway, it's just an idea flopping around in my head. More on that
another day.


So I'm not sure what I want to say in comparison of Dr. Neufeld's theory of parenting vs. my theory of trust, but I'm inclined to think that Dr. Neufeld might agree with my little thesis. I'll have to keep figuring out my theory and turn it into a full-fledged article. Someday.